10 Tastiest Lobster Rolls In NYC You Need To Try Right Now
It may be the summer of hot dogs in NYC, but we’re one-upping it and saying it’s the summer of…lobster rolls?! Who says you need to go New England or Long Island to find the best one when there’s plenty of mouthwatering places to get one in the Big Apple.
To make the most of #LobsterRollSummer we’ve done the hard work and gathered the best spots to find one (with a little help from our followers of course). Here’s where to find that flaky, buttery lobster roll for when you have your next summer craving.
1. Luke’s Lobster, Multiple Locations
With multiple “shacks” around NYC, there’s no shortage of Luke’s Lobster and thank goodness! Their Lobster Roll comes served either warm or Maine style, which means chilled lobster, a swipe of mayo, lemon butter, and that utterly delicious Luke’s Secret Seasoning. It’ll run you $23 – $34 depending on if you get the 4 oz or 6 oz option…and we recommend pairing it with the mouthwatering New England Clam Chowder and oyster crackers. Find one near you and book it this summer, trust us. See all of Luke’s Lobster’s menus here.
Where: Find your location here
2. Cull & Pistol, Chelsea
Cull & Pistol is actually a full-service restaurant offspring of Lobster Place (further down this list), and the lobster rolls here are some of the absolute best. For $37, you can order their Lobster Roll either cold (chilled lobster salad with mayo and scallions) OR hot (knuckle & claw meat, warmed lobster butter, fines herbes, Kewpie mayo & lemon) —both equally delicious. While you’re at it spoil yourself with some oysters, their specialty which come from Canada, New England, and beyond…don’t forget to thank us later. See Cull & Pistol’s full menu here!
Where: 75 9th Ave
3. The Fulton by Jean-Georges, Seaport
We frequent The Fulton by Jean-Georges for many reasons, the waterfront setting, the brand name chef, but most importantly…the lobster roll. It’s the hidden gem in Seaport in our opinion, and you can only snag it up during their lunch hours from 11:30 am – 2:30 pm Monday – Friday.
The Maine Lobster Roll, which we think Chef Jean-Georges blesses himself, comes out with loads of whole claw meat plopped into a divine buttered potato bun topped with celery, lettuce, and spices. Pair it with their in-house made potato chips and it’s the best little upscale bite you’ll ever have. See The Fulton’s full menu here!
Where: 89 South St
4. North River Lobster Company, Pier 81
Hop aboard the city’s only floating lobster shack and dig into a roll…because nothing quite beats a lobster roll on the water. North River Lobster Company actually offers 4 different options that tingle our tastebuds, which include the Classic Lobster Roll on a potato bun, the Connecticut Roll served warm with melted butter on a potato roll, the Double Truffle Roll with truffle oil mayo on a potato bun with truffle parmesan fries, and our favorite (and the most interesting) the Lower East Side Roll with scallion cream cheese and red onions on an everything roll. The bites and the views are all chef’s kiss. See North River Lobster Company’s full menus here.
Where: Pier 81 W 41st St
5. Red Hook Lobster Pound, Red Hook
Red Hook, Brooklyn might be a trek for some New Yorkers, but it’s definitely worth the hike…especially with it potentially being the best lobster roll in Brooklyn. The nautical-themed spot is just a block from the waterfront, and their special “Lobster Roll” section will have you debating what to order for hours.
They of course have the traditional Maine-Style (cold) and Connecticut-Style (warm) rolls, but we suggest venturing out to their other options like the California Roll (Maine lobster salad, lettuce, cucumber, avocado), BLT (lobster salad, chipotle mayo, applewood smoked bacon topped with paprika and scallions), or Fried Lobster Roll (fried lobster tossed in lobster caramel sauce with kewpie mayo). See their full menu and plan a visit here!
Where: 284 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn
6. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co., Greenpoint
Head to Greenpoint, Brooklyn to get your hands on this tasty roll, which comes served with a choice of mayo or butter. The heaps of lobster knuckles covered in zesty lemon flavor will have you crawling back for more. It’ll run you $34, and we suggest taste testing some other menu items while you’re there because it’s all so fresh. See Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.’s full menu here!
Where: 114 Nassau Ave, Brooklyn
7. Grand Banks, Pier 25
Hop aboard the historic wooden schooner, Sherman Zwicker, and order one of Grand Banks’ Lobster Rolls, which includes Maine lobster with herb-dulse emulsion and pickled cucumber on a griddled potato bun. The floating oyster bar on an old fishing boat vibe is the perfect place to scarf down one of these puppies. See Grand Banks’ full menu here.
Where: Pier 25, Hudson River Park
8. Jeffrey’s Grocery, West Village
This West Village staple is vouchable for many reasons, but one of their main ones is because of their lobster rolls. Jeffrey’s Grocery serves their rendition with herb mayo, pickled cucumber, and house chips and will cost you $35. The best part is it’s served all day and night long. See Jeffrey’s Grocery’s full menu here.
Where: 172 Waverly Pl
9. Mark’s Off Madison, NoMad
When we found this spot on TikTok we were a little skeptical at first, but Mark’s Off Madison definitely lives up to the hype. Their lobster rolls are packed to the brim and are served in finely toasted buns with a side of crinkly chips. We’re in awe every time we come here because there’s so many incredible sandwich options to choose from. See their full menu here!
Where: 41 Madison Ave Ground Level
10. Lobster Place, Chelsea Market
Last but not least is maybe one of the OG spots in NYC for lobster rolls, Lobster Place. With a name like that, you just know they’re good. It’s actually located inside Chelsea Market where you can order one up amongst your shopping travels throughout the famous stalls. They’re served in either 4 or 6 oz increments here, packed with claw & tail meat, celery, scallions, lemon & mayo. Browse the fish market right near after, it’s pretty neat. See Lobster Place’s full menu here.
Where: 75 9th Ave
The post 10 Tastiest Lobster Rolls In NYC You Need To Try Right Now appeared first on Secret NYC.